The Pole by J.M. Coetzee – a Book Review

Coming in at only 166 pages, this little volume barely constitutes a book, but it manages to just tip the scale between novella and novel. This is deliberate on the part of Coetzee who has opted for what is described as “late style.” This phrase was coined in 1937 by philosopher Theodor Adorno who described it this way: “The maturity of the late works does not resemble the kind one finds in fruit. They are for the most part not round, but furrowed, even ravaged. Devoid of sweetness, bitter and spiny, they do not surrender themselves to mere delectation.” In hindsight, that does perfectly summarize this book. We see an aging artist laid bare, stripped down to the raw and ravaged sinew of a once formidable body. Even the cover of the book is simple and abrupt. The keys of the piano as shown are reduced to one octave ranging from A to G. Even this seems to suggest the shortening of time as one inches closer to mortality.

The Pole is told from the perspective of Beatriz, a resident of Barcelona who becomes the fixation of the aging pianist Wittold Walccyzkiecz. Though Beatriz seems to find the pianist utterly unimpressive and almost odious, she allows herself to get swept into his world. At times her disdain for everything from his physical form to his music seems to border on cruelty, the reading of which becomes so uncomfortable. This man, admired by the rest of the world as a master musician and powerful presence, is reduced to seeming pathetic under the gaze of Beatriz who is content to take and take and take without giving even the slightest hint of affection in return. As we read more into Beatriz’s psyche, we can view this as her own delusion, an inability or unwillingness to admit to her feeling. Her life and her marriage are no longer satisfying to her, but she keeps up appearances to both herself and the rest of the world because that’s what she is programmed to believe she must do.

I want to hate Beatriz, but I can’t. I understand her to a certain extent. I think most of us can relate to the conflict of inner desire versus outward presentation. Defer, deflect, deny, even to oneself. Upon initially closing this book your initial thought will probably be, “well that was depressing.” Upon intense reflection you’re able to piece together just how psychological it all really is, which actually makes it even more depressing.

The format of this novel is quite unique. It’s broken up into chapters and then further into what I can only describe as stanzas, the paragraphs being numbered and separated into their own separate groupings. Admittedly, while I once had quite a bit of musical training, I really don’t remember much about the structure of classical music, but the structure of this novel does make me think that Coetzee is structuring it in a way to mimic the movements of a symphony or concerto. Were I inclined to put the same amount of work into it as I might a thesis, perhaps I’d explore this, but I have seven more reviews to catch up on so I’m going to punk out on that idea. Let’s not and say we did, shall we? Either way, I think this is a very clever device that I initially found jarring, but once I fell into the flow it made a bit more sense.

In the simplest of terms, I can’t say that I enjoyed reading this book, but I am glad that I did.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Published September 19, 2023 by Liveright. ISBN 9781324093862. Hardcover. 166 pages.

Posted in General fiction, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young- a Book Review

Adrienne Young is quite the prolific author, predominantly writing young adult fantasy but branching out lately to release more adult material. I’ve been under a rock, apparently, because this beautiful novel is the first of hers I’ve had the pleasure of reading. The Unmaking of June Farrow follows, you guessed it, June Farrow. She’s the last in a long line of Farrow women, women who are cursed to suffer the slow descent into mental decline. June is determined to be the last of this cursed line. She will remain alone, never to bring a daughter into the world to suffer the same fate. Now in her thirties, the hallucinations begin and June prepares herself for the end. However, as the hallucinations become ever more powerful, June begins to suspect there’s more to the story of the Farrow women than she’s previously been told. They aren’t just different. They are special in a way the rest of the world could never understand. The more she uncovers, the more June realizes she may not just have to let the curse die with her. She could stop it from plaguing future generations of her family once and for all.

I literally just finished the audiobook version of this novel. I positively loved it. I really can’t say a lot about the plot, unfortunately, because there are so many twists in this journey and the reading experience is totally rooted in the discovery. Granted, there were a few details that weren’t at all surprising to me. There is a murder, for instance, but I thought it was pretty clear from the start who committed the murder. It’s not a murder mystery, after all. It’s much more complex than that.

Time travel plays a major role in this novel. Years ago I settled on the idea that no matter how hard I may try, I will never be able to fully wrap my mind around the concept of time travel. Answers will always lead to more questions and then I’ll eventually either confuse myself into mental oblivion or come to the conclusion it’s just not freaking possible and nothing makes any sense. Trying to fully comprehend the sheer scope of this particular time travel thread made me feel like I was a member of the Farrow family, slowly losing my mind. Trust me when I say you just need to let go and let it be. Screw the logic. The human story is worth it in the end. The story is a lovely escape, and it’s ultimately about the power of love and the strength of the family bond.

This book is excellent in audio, and I really enjoyed the soothing Carolina drawl that the narrator, Brittany Pressley, enacted for its telling. The characters are strong, each well thought out and believable. It’s well paced and peppered with excitement, including some steamy love scenes if that’s your jam. The setting, as well, is quite rich and vibrant. Overall, I’d say this is one of my favorite books of the year if I’m judging by sheer enjoyment factor.

Rating: 5 out of 5.

Published Oct 17, 2023 by Random House Audio. ISBN 9780593598672. Runtime 10 hrs, 7 mins. Narrated by Brittany Pressley.

Posted in Fantasy, magical realism, Uncategorized | Tagged , , | 2 Comments

Apples of Stone by Philip Marsh – a Book Review

Philip Marsh was a local author, poet, and licensed clinical social worker based in the Ozarks where I live. I never got the chance to meet him, but I do know his brother, a lawyer in Springfield, who passed along Philip’s novel to me. The author passed away in March of 2021 from complications from pneumonia and multiple sclerosis, a disease he’d battled for almost 40 years. Despite these trials in his life, Marsh managed to truly leave his mark on the community in which he lived. Apples of Stone was his only novel. It is very loosely based on the Times Beach, Missouri, environmental disaster. If you mention Times Beach to any Missouri native who was alive and coherent in the 80’s, you’ll probably receive a somber nod of recognition. It was a big deal, and a ghost town was left in its wake to prove just what a big deal it was.

Let’s just drop a disclaimer right now. This is not a book that’s going to leave you feeling warm and fuzzy. The goodreads synopsis for this novel reads: “It is also a tragedy involving altruism, human weakness, and corporate greed.” That all becomes abundantly clear once you start reading this. Is it worth it? I think so, though I did have my issues with it. Quite major issues, actually.

First of all, I absolutely hated the main character, Elliot. I don’t use that word lightly. I hated this guy. He was selfish, arrogant, more than a little stupid, and a raging misogynist. Mind you, it was the 1980’s and it’s the Ozarks, so I guess most men were this exact dude and many still are. I am in no way under the illusion that I’m supposed to like Elliot. Marsh was a smart man. He knew what he was writing, and I have a feeling he knew a few of these gems of toxic manhood disguised as altruistic liberals. Elliot had good intentions, sure. He was willing to put himself on the line for his community. He fought for justice and brought light to a serious environmental issue when no one else would. He just makes a LOT of mistakes, all of which are tied to his penis. Not literally, ouch. I mean, we all know that the penis is the holy and divine gift from God to the male species that ensures they never have to be held accountable for anything ever again.

I mean, this is basically an Ozarks Shakespearean tragedy. The Montagues and Capulets are going to screw up so many times you have no choice but to clutch your almost empty bottle of wine while slumped against the wall decrying the imminent demise of humanity. TAKE ME NOW, CRUEL WORLD!! Come to think of it, I think there’s a deleted Avengers scene where Thanos reads this book and then decides to annihilate half of humanity. Frankly, I’m not 100% certain he didn’t have a point.

I have to talk about the part I don’t really want to talk about but I feel it necessary. I despise having to hate on female characters, but Julene positively sucks! Why does Julene exist? Why does there have to be a slutty temptress who spouts misogynistic BS into the ear of our main character to make things even worse? And why the ever-loving-hell is she his cousin giving this the ever-so-icky theme of Ozarkian incest? I tried to sympathize with Julene, I really did. I do feel as a woman in the 1980’s there are certain things about her that I admire. She is fiery and gives zero fucks about what anyone thinks of her, and I absolutely admire that. But when she confidently told Elliot that if lets his wife wear the pants, so to speak, she’d never respect him, I let out an audible gasp of disgust.

I believe this is one of those cases where a man of a previous generation struggles to write a female character that isn’t a caricature of womanhood. She’s sexy, immoral and manipulative, and not quite smart enough to not need the man to fight her battles for her. And Elliot is just as culpable as Julene, but somehow we’re left with this vague notion that everything is her fault and Elliot is just a victim of her diabolical feminine wiles. Don’t get me started on the poor wife. That woman deserved so much better than the life she was given on this planet, and I wish she’d been given the grit and determination of Julene. Instead, she’s a totally different caricature of the weak and simpering wife who pretends she doesn’t but really does need the man to complete her. Ultimately, I get what Marsh was trying to convey, especially after things come to an inevitable conclusion that I won’t discuss for giving anything away. Greed and selfishness reign supreme no matter how much money you have or how good your intentions may be.

I felt the best and most important character in this was Paul, Elliot’s brother. A former professional baseball player now experiencing crippling pain, Paul wrestles with the dissipation of his former glory and imminent mortality. It was Paul’s terminal cancer diagnosis that originally alerted Elliot to the environmental dangers affecting the community, issues that became even more clear when Elliot connected with neighbors experiencing strange symptoms that couldn’t possibly exist by coincidence in such a small geographic area. Frankly, I think there was something really powerful about Paul’s story that got overshadowed by Elliot’s lusting after his damn cousin for most of the novel.

Don’t let David or I dissuade you from picking this one up. As long as the People suck and then you die theme isn’t a total turnoff for you, there’s a lot of depth in this story. I mean… they don’t ALL die, though some people probably deserved it, but that’s just life. As much as he may like to, Thanos can’t actually snap his fingers and make ONLY the sucky people disappear. We’d lose some good ones and be stuck with some douche canoes. This is why we have wine and ice cream.

Marsh was a skilled writer. The pacing is good. The characters may be terrible people, for the most part, but they certainly aren’t lacking in complexity. There’s some action and excitement along the way, and even some surprises, though most of those also aren’t good surprises. Overall, however, upon reflection I’m glad I read this one and it is a story that will stick with me.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Published June 16, 2013 by LuLu publishing. ISBN 9781304117755. Paperback. 382 pages.

Posted in General fiction, Legal Thriller, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Horrorstör by Grady Hendrix – a Book Review

I have never been to one, but I know many people believe there’s nothing on this Earth more terrifying than an IKEA. They balk at the idea of entering the humongous chain store in which one could easily get lost, and they especially balk at taking home a jigsaw puzzle-esque project likely to push them over the edge into insanity. Grady Hendix knows this, and he is playing upon their fears in the most delightful way.

He introduces us to Orsk, a Scandinavian mega-giant chain store offering home and office furnishings for those who like difficult projects that wreak havoc on one’s mental health. Our lead character is Amy, the most unlikely of final girls, an employee who happens to hate her job and isn’t really very good at anything. Frankly, she doesn’t care enough to ever be good at anything, or that’s at least the vibe she gives off to the rest of the world. However, Amy needs money quite badly so she accepts an extra overnight shift from Basil, her excessively annoying manager, to stay at Orsk and try to catch whoever has been vandalizing the place at night. Together with Basil and a handful of other employees, Amy will figure out that the huge Scandinavian chain store is, in fact, trying to kill us all.

Honestly, the sheer premise of this book is delightful. The execution for it was decent. It is a little rushed. As a short volume, he could have even expanded on a little more and I would have been totally ok with it. I would like to get my hands on an actual copy, as I notice it’s crafted to look like a store catalog, and that’s pretty awesome. As I listened to it, I found Bronson Pinchot’s radio-announcer interludes advertising products that introduce each chapter to be positively fabulous, especially as they take on a creepy tone.

As seems to be in typical Grady Hendrix fashion, this book goes from tame standard mystery fare into vomit-inducing gross gory goop at the snap of your fingers. Truly, Grady Hendrix isn’t for the squeamish. Otherwise, it’s a good mix of moderate scares and humorous dialogue. Honestly, I found the history behind the supernatural aspect to be sad, made more horrifying by the fact I know it’s in some way based upon institutions guilty of similar atrocities than in any kind of supernatural horror aspect. I enjoyed Amy as a main character, especially for her unique leading lady quality and her ability to grow and rise to the occasion as the story progressed.

Overall, I liked it, but I think I will remember it mostly for its truly original concept versus the actual story, but it was a really good choice for a Halloween season read.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Published September 23, 2014 by Blackstone Publishing. ISBN 9781483049786. Narrated by Tai Sammons and Bronson Pinchot. Runtime 6 hrs, 16 mins.

Posted in Horror, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

The Stargazer’s Sister by Carrie Brown – a Book Review

I love this kind of book. The Stargazer’s Sister is the mostly-true story of Caroline Herschel, the also famous sister of legendary astronomer, William Herschel. Anyone with even a passing interest in astronomy will know his name, and even those without that passing interest are familiar with some of his discoveries. Ever heard of Uranus? Yeah, he found it. No big deal, right? He perfected the design of the telescope allowing humans to visually reach farther into the universe than ever before. William features heavily in this novel, but Lina, as Caroline is better known, is the true star.

A brilliant astronomer in her own right, Lina would go on to discover numerous comets, one of which bears her name. She was the first female scientist to receive a salary, the first woman in England to hold a government position, the first to be awarded a Gold Medal of the Royal Astronomical Society, and a few other firsts. Standing at just 4 foot-3 inches tall, Caroline Herschel was still a total badass, especially considering she had to work extra hard in order to convince people to take her seriously simply for being a woman. Caroline and William remained extremely close throughout their lives, with Caroline originally living with William and working as his assistant. When William married in 1788, Caroline left the home and went out on her own. While some view her as a jealous and bitter woman who felt cast out, I think this is way too simplistic of an outlook. In reality, while it may have stung being forced out of the only home she’d ever known, Caroline took the opportunity to achieve more independence, and this period is when her own accomplishments began to shine. She didn’t wallow. She rose above and kept bettering her own life.

The real question is how does all of this factor into the novel? Brown does take quite a few liberties, but the spirit of Caroline’s story is quite intact. Brown begins with Caroline’s early life, a difficult life with a miserable and uncaring mother from whom William offered her an escape. Under William’s tutelage Caroline thrived, discovering and exploring the depths of her own intellect. She managed every aspect of the household while also juggling her academic duties as William’s assistant. Frankly, if the novel is to be believed, William wouldn’t have achieved near as much without Lina’s tireless efforts to assist him, keeping everything in order so that he could pour all of his time and energy into developing his telescopes.

Brown effortlessly and authentically captures the essence of Lina. She is complex, both aware of her intellectual prowess while also possessing almost crippling doubts about her worth as a woman. She adores and idolizes her brother but is fully aware of and accepting of his faults. At times, I even found Brown’s depictions of Lina’s feelings for William as verging over into the inappropriate category. Somewhat of a savior complex, I presume. The biggest criticism I see from other readers is that it is long and not a lot happens. What does happen materializes slowly. These readers aren’t wrong, but I didn’t find myself being bothered by it. I enjoyed reading this book and was content to follow Lina’s story for a while, even if it meandered through the drudgery of her day to day existence. In the late 1700’s and early 1800’s, women’s lives were not full of adventure. For God’s sake, I picked up a historical fiction book about 18th century astronomers. I didn’t expect them to actually go to space. Lina was a work horse, and she deserved any manner and amount of accolades that eventually came her way. I guarantee you she deserved a lot more than she actually received.

There was one liberty Brown took in introducing us to William and Lina’s lives that I don’t agree with, as it makes no sense to me. Brown presents to us readers that William Herschel and his wife, Mary Baldwin Herschel, were never able to have children and this was a great sorrow for them both. This is purely contrived. In fact, the couple’s son, Sir John Frederick William Herschel was a famed mathematician, astronomer, chemist, inventor and photographer. He was a big fucking deal! Additionally, Lina shared a very deep bond with her nephew that would last beyond her brother’s death. I feel like Brown replaced John with her contrived character of Stanley, who didn’t really add all that much to the story except for his place as a companion for Lina, and she could have just as easily used John and remained more authentic in her representation of this family’s history. In fact, she cuts off his whole bloodline. John would go on to have TWELVE CHILDREN. There are all kinds of William Herschel descendants bopping around this planet today, and Carrie Brown robbed him of a large part of his legacy. Of all the things to take a writer’s license with, I thought this was an odd choice.

Overall, I enjoyed the writing, and I applaud the fact that Carrie Brown gave a wonderful woman from history a real voice. Caroline Herschel is definitely someone to be celebrated.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Published January 19, 2016 by Pantheon. ISBN 9780804197939. 352 pages. Hardcover.

Posted in Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized, Women's fiction | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

The People We Keep by Allison Larkin – a Book Review

The People We Keep follows 16-year-old April Sawicki. Living alone in a motorhome technically owned by her deadbeat dad, her mother existing only in memories from before she ran off, April has only her own grit and willingness to break laws in order to survive. In order to live, she has her music, her one true link to something real and lasting. After a vicious fight with her father, April decides to set off on her own in search of a place and people who could actually feel like home.

This is a beautiful book, and at times it’s very difficult to read. April is the kind of damaged that can’t be fixed overnight. Beneath her desire to find something lasting is a fear of being abandoned. The result is that she doesn’t know how to stay anywhere. She doesn’t know how to keep anyone because she doesn’t believe she’s worthy of being kept. It would be easy to look at April and judge her, but we are talking about a child. The need for survival makes selfish beasts of us all whether we want such a life or not. April is a scared child just looking for a lifeline. She has to lie, steal, and run in order to protect herself. Or so she thinks, because it’s the only thing she’s ever known. People, in her experience, only ever want from you what you can give to them. There’s never anything given in return. It’s beautiful to watch April encounter people along the way who show her that love and trust are possible. Her journey to discovering she actually deserves love and trust is a frustrating but authentically drawn.

I do love that Larkin didn’t really make this a romance. There are elements of that, but ultimately each instance takes a backseat to the more lasting and more powerful theme of friendship. And with every relationship April finds herself in, whether friend or lover, April discovers her own power to wound or heal. This is a simple story about complicated aspects of life, and it’s both beautiful and heartbreaking.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Published August 3, 2021 by Simon and Schuster Audio. ISBN 9781797124360. Runtime 11 hrs, 8 mins. Narrated by Julia Whelan.

Posted in Coming of Age, General fiction, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

A House With Good Bones by T. Kingfisher – a Book Review

October is a busy month for most of us in my book club, Read Between the Wines, and this month it was my choice for book selection. I chose this short and quick Southern Gothic paranormal mystery for something easy to tackle but also season-appropriate. While Kingfisher has published quite a bit, this is the first of her books I’ve had the pleasure of reading.

Synopsis

The book follows Sam Montgomery, a young woman who returns home on an extended break from work to stay with her mother in the house that used to be occupied by her mysterious and prickly grandmother. Sam finds that her mother is acting quite strangely and odd things start happening around the house. With nothing but time on her hands and a growing sense of paranoia, Sam decides to investigate to get to the bottom of the strange happenings plaguing her home.

Review

I know what you might be thinking. That synopsis sounds like a million other books I’ve read in the genre. You’d be right. The “girl returns to creepy old house and experiences creepy stuff” thing has been done a lot, but this book does add its own unique vibe to it. First of all, Sam is quite relatable for your everyday human. She’s overweight, a bit boring, and isn’t exactly winning any popularity contests. She spends most of her time at her mother’s house lounging on the couch with snacks watching detective shows when she isn’t begrudgingly working on dead bug classification. You see, Sam is an archaeoentomologist. She doesn’t just study bugs. She studies long-dead bugs. Yep, that’s a job that people do willingly. Sam may be pretty passionate about what she does for a living, but not a lot of people want to listen to a grown woman drone on about her fascination with dead bugs. While this book does drift super dark toward the end, Sam lends a certain amount of quick-witted humor to keep things from getting overwhelmingly distressing. Most of the book we spend swimming around in her internal monologue, which could be painfully dull with the wrong narrator. Frankly, I enjoyed spending time with Sam’s thoughts. Her perspective is unique and refreshing. While secondary characters are a bit sparse, those that do make an appearance are memorable and well-drawn. They add something important to the ambience.

The last quarter of the novel brings about a very abrupt tonal shift. One moment we’re loping along with Sam’s thoughts, analyzing weird ladybug activity, and the next we are surging forward into darkness, chaos and a nightmare full of creepy-crawly awfulness. It is jarring, to say the least. As far as plot is concerned, there’s not really much of a mystery. The reader is given plenty of hints along the way, and we have formulated an accurate portrait well before Sam has stumbled onto the truth. I seriously doubt I’m the only one who felt this way. Nothing was surprising in the least. The only thing surprising is that ladybugs were used as a device in a horror novel.

Scary, right? Kingfisher obviously doesn’t play by the rules, and I respect that. I thoroughly expect her next book to include a horde of horrifying hamsters, if only for the alliterative quality.

In short, I found this book to be quick but enjoyable. I’m looking forward to reading more of Kingfisher’s work in the future.

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

Published March 28, 2023 by Tor Nightfire. ISBN 9781250829795. Hardcover. 247 pages.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

All the Ugly and Wonderful Things by Bryn Greenwood – a Book Review

I’m struggling with how to even start this review. It will be heavy, and more than slightly uncomfortable. Honestly, I’m kind of wishing I never lifted this book off the shelf. Maybe that’s why I haven’t posted a review SINCE MAY!!! Good God, what’s wrong with me?

In lieu of giving a formal synopsis, I’m just going to jump in. Our main character is Wavy, a waifish child of an abusive meth-dealing father who mostly ignores her existence, and a chronically depressed mother who spends all her days in a drug-fueled semi-conscious purgatory. Wavy spends her nights memorizing constellations and sneaking food, and she spends her days keeping her little brother alive since no one else seems up to the job. Essentially, this girl never got the chance to be a child. There are mental and emotional things going on here that would require professional help. What she gets instead, however, is a similarly-troubled young man named Kellen. She witnesses him wreck his motorcycle and comes to his aid at the age of 8, and the two develop a friendship. Over the course of the novel, however, their friendship develops into something more.

Ok, first of all, I will not be talking about how romantic this book is. You can not have a romance between a man and a child. What I did see, and it was done really well, are two people who actually take the time to see each other when no one else will. I can see how a bond would form between those two people. However, Kellen met Wavy when she was 8 years old. By the time she is 13, their relationship has become, if not overtly sexual, sexually charged. At this point, Kellen is 25. This is where I can’t be on board. It’s not as if his attraction to her grew over time. It grew in intensity, but he admits to wrecking his motorcycle because the sight of her standing there blinded him and he thought she was an angel. She was the most beautiful thing he’d ever seen. SHE IS AN EIGHT YEAR OLD WHO IS DESCRIBED AS LOOKING EXTREMELY YOUNG FOR HER AGE!

All that being said, Greenwood is a fabulous writer. Her characters are raw, realistic, and intensely complicated to the point of being utterly problematic. I did not dislike this book, but it left me feeling so conflicted I was a bit queasy. Frankly, I don’t dislike Kellen. I probably should feel like he groomed Wavy, but I don’t think that at all. Not intentionally, anyway. I believe he was very conflicted about his feelings for her, and Wavy honestly seemed to be the more aggressive one in this relationship. However, Wavy had grown up seeing women as commodity. They were there as something to be used by men. Considering this, she does not have a healthy view of love or relationships. She would feel she owes him something in return for his kindness. We are talking about a little girl who’s witnessed her own father receiving blow jobs from the various women he keeps around for his amusement right under the nose of his half-comatose wife. While Kellen does his best not to take advantage of Wavy, he still plays with fire way too much. If you know you should not be having inappropriate relations with a little girl, you shouldn’t sneak up to her bedroom at night and sleep in her bed. Frankly, both of these individuals need some serious mental health help before they can pursue any kind of fulfilling relationship.

See? There’s a consensus.

I’m not going to go into the ending, but let’s just say it does nothing to assuage these problematic feelings. I will give Greenwood credit for coming up with something moving, original, and intensely thought provoking, but I’m going to close this chapter of my reading life with giving this one 3 stars. And then I’m going to try to forget about the icky feelings this one inspires.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

Published August 9, 2016 by Thomas Dunne Books. ISBN 9781250153968. 432 pages. Hardcover.

Posted in General fiction, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

Lessons in Chemistry by Bonnie Garmus – a Book Review

Let me first preface this review by saying this is at once the most infuriating and most wondrous book I’ve read in a very long time. At first glance, I didn’t think this book would be an articulate work of women’s fiction celebrating a brilliant and beleaguered scientist fighting her way through a world of utter shit bags. From the cover art, I prejudged it as being just another feel-good schmaltzy romance. Not that there’s anything wrong with that on certain occasions, but schmaltzy romances don’t usually make my blood boil and give me dreams of kicking misogynists in the balls repeatedly until they repent of their sins. There were times in this book I quite justifiably wanted to maim someone. Only really bad people, of course. I am the Dexter of women’s fiction.

It is the early 1960’s and chemist Elizabeth Zott becomes an unlikely television sensation with her breakthrough cooking show, Supper at Six. From a platform she never thought she’d hold and truly never wanted, she’s able to reach millions of women to show them a life they’ve never been allowed to pursue. As we learn more about Elizabeth’s past, it brings her present into such raw and stunning clarity, and it’s more than a little heartbreaking. It’s a true and touching tribute to the women who came before our present generation who refused to be disrespected and denied due credit for their accomplishments.

The greatest attribute of this book is character development. There was not one character who wasn’t properly crafted and presented. There are those who are imperfect but utterly lovable, and then there are those devoid of all manner of human decency. In other words, perfectly realistic! That isn’t sarcasm, btw. I actually mean that. I came to adore Elizabeth, her daughter, Mad, and their dog, 6:30. There were also characters who experienced intense growth through their interactions with Elizabeth. Some characters, one in particular, who absolutely infuriated me in the beginning of the novel I wound up liking by the end. One of the things I hate about our society of today is we seem incapable of offering people grace and compassion for prior bad ideas and actions. If we learn from our mistakes, why don’t we allow people to make mistakes and grow as humans? I mean, if they are still shit bags then I’ll see you at the weenie roast. I’ll bring wine.

I’ve read numerous reviews by other readers, and I can tell by the responses that people either love or hate this book. The biggest critique I’ve seen of the book is with Elizabeth’s personality. On the whole, Elizabeth does come across as cold and unemotional. Readers reject the idea that simply because she’s a scientist she would be devoid of emotion. Of course scientists have emotions. Just being analytical doesn’t mean you are incapable of feeling. This is fair, and I agree. However, I don’t agree that Elizabeth is unemotional only because of her love for and interest in science. She obviously feels emotions, and I think Garmus actually shows this quite well. She show’s Elizabeth’s suppression of these emotions because there is no other way to make it in a male-dominated field unless she is a total rock.

Even today I have known women like this when it’s far easier to be a woman in a male-dominated work culture. Who cares if a man would be described as a confident go-getter but a woman is labeled an emotionless bitch. Get it done, sister. A woman like Elizabeth Zott knows she will have to have an exterior twice as tough, a brain twice as smart, and the mental fortitude of all her colleagues combined in order to gain even half the respect of the dumbest imbecile on the team. If I had to choose between hiding in a bathroom stall weeping or kicking some ass, I think I know which I would pick. You do what you know and fight for the right to do it. If they don’t let you and tell you to get back to the kitchen, do a damn cooking show and teach some bored, unhappy housewives about chemistry while you’re at it. Was Elizabeth a rare find among 1950’s/60’s women? Yes. Was she an as-yet formed species that was never observed in the wild? Not even close. There were badass bitches long before Elizabeth Zott came around. Sadly, we don’t know many of their names or faces because their work was pilfered by lazy assholes who held the magic wands of instant and undeniable credibility. Why yes, this is absolutely astounding work. Just show us the penis to prove you were able to craft it independently and we’ll give you the credit you deserve.

I think you’re probably starting to imagine why this book made me so angry. Not irrationally angry… just angry. I still loved it. I loved the characters and the way the story unfolded. I loved the subtle nuances of the relationships that were forged among the characters. I don’t see myself ever using scientific principles to become good at rowing. No amount of science can fix this level of poor fitness. I would still die the first time I pick up a paddle, but yay for Elizabeth for figuring it out.

You really should read this book. Separate yourself from the men in your life. Put away all sharp objects, number 2 pencils, and any and all varieties of poisonous mushrooms. Then go read this book. You’ll both curse and thank me later.

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Published April 5, 2022 by Random House Audio. First published March 31, 2022 by Doubleday Books. ISBN 9780593507537. Runtime 11 hrs, 55 mins. Narrated by Miranda Raison.

Posted in General fiction, Literary Fiction, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

The Bear and the Nightingale (The Winternight Trilogy #1) by Katherine Arden – a Book Review

I stumbled upon this book on the shelf at the local library. The cover screamed “ATMOSPHERIC,” so it pulled me in. It is a blend of Russian folklore and medieval fantasy. It follows young Vasilisa (“Vasya”), the daughter of the local village leader. Vasya is an odd girl, wild and free and most at home in the forest or with the horses. She sees ancient creatures that no one else can see, the creatures of folklore that care for the home, the forests, the lakes, and the wildlife.

Her mother having died after Vasya’s birth, her father goes to Moscow and brings back a wife, a strange devout woman who takes an instant dislike to Vasya. This new stepmother also sees the creatures of folklore, but she views them as demons that should be cast out. Also arriving is an enigmatic priest whose feelings for Vasya are complicated. She both disgusts and entrances him, her unholy presence a threat to both the people of the town and his own fragile soul. The priest insists that only God can cleanse the village of the evils that have befallen it. You know the story. It’s all your fault. Repent, wring your hands, fall on your knees and give yourself over to God and everything will be ok. Only Vasya continues to bring offerings to the creatures that have protected and served the people for hundreds of years. As they grow weaker while people forget, they begin to fade. They become unsettled and angry, and darkness and difficulty befalls the people of her village. As the conflict bubbles to the surface, Vasya and the kindly forces of nature will find themselves battling evils of devastating power both within the town and from deep within the forest.

This story is wildly inventive and beautifully written. Vasya is the kind of heroine you can’t help but love. She’s wild, independent, fiercely honorable and protective. Above all, she’s smart and courageous, if only a bit reckless. It’s this recklessness that forces her to action when there is desperate need. She’s not gullible in the face of fear-mongering. It’s not just supernatural ability that causes her to see more than most. She’s able to think critically when others shut down, and she refuses to allow the weak minded to prey upon her fears. This story may be from a bygone day, but it will always be relevant. Forget the fairy tales of the damsels in distress who sleep through all the action.

There is something melancholy about this story in what it represents. I adore the old legends of ancient folklore, but they have faded from the minds and hearts of people. In so many cultures, they were forced out by powerful invaders who brought their own religions they mandated as the truth. Over time, the people didn’t realize they had taken up the weapon as their own and left behind the stories and fables of their ancestors. Thank goodness for the written word that exists in celebration of these historical gems. The presence of legend and magic can still be felt and I think they can still make a comeback. I hope so, because I’d be very willing to leave out tasty treats for the domovoi if they’d help me keep my house clean.

The only thing I had difficulty with this book is keeping track of all the Russian terminology. Even character names got complicated because they were referred to alternately by given names or nicknames/shortened or adapted versions/etc. While this is probably 100% culturally accurate, it can spark some confusion. And when you aren’t familiar with the folklore, the names of some creatures could sound quite similar and run together. Arden did include a helpful glossary of terms, which is extremely helpful. I feel like once I got my bearings things became a lot easier.

4 stars for this unique fairy tale.

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Published January 10, 2017 by Del Rey. ISBN 9781101885932. Hardcover. 319 pages.

Posted in Fantasy, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment